Pi Bakerie

N P 3 months ago

What a wonderful find!! 😀 Everything about this place looks, feels, and tastes like it was made ever so carefully and thoughtfully so that people would have the best possible experience. There are even bookshelves with beautiful picture books about Greek culture. Plus there’s a beautiful garden with seating outside. And the staff were genuinely nice! I could go on and on saying positive things. What a gem! 💎✨

Ioanna 4 months ago

High quality food, flavorful ingredients, authentic Greek flavors in pastries, pies and sweets. Bougatsa is one of the best I've had even in Thessaloniki, also highly recommend tyropita, spanakopita, portokalopita and gigandes beans. Great coffee and service. The atmosphere is vibrant and cozy and the environment always clean.

Carl Reviews Edited 2 months ago

We visited Pi Bakery on Cedar Street in Manhattan on a cold, snowy day, and it was the perfect cosy escape from the weather. The place was warm and welcoming, and we enjoyed a delicious warm apple pie that was absolutely gorgeous. They even whipped up some cream to go with it. The staff were exceptionally friendly and helpful. We also had a hot chocolate and an Earl Grey tea, both of which were spot on. It was simply lovely to receive such genuinely excellent service, and we would happily return. Unfortunately, our return visit in July was disappointing. The service was noticeably less friendly, and the prices now seem extremely high. We ordered the apple pie they are known for and asked whether we could have cream or ice cream on the side, but neither was available. Instead, we were offered a single scoop of Greek yoghurt, which was charged at $4 per person. That felt excessive for what was provided. The food is still good, but the overall pricing is becoming very difficult to justify, particularly when the service no longer feels as welcoming as it did before.

Rachel S 9 months ago

Stopped by Pi Bakerie craving baklava. The mini size was just right. I ended up trying the meatballs and Gigantes. The tomato sauce on the meatballs was flavorful but not heavy, and the Gigantes were nicely cooked and tasty. Cozy spot to sit inside, with friendly staff. Simple place for dessert or a savory bite.

Ada Kiugo 10 months ago

If you find yourself in NYC’s Financial District and want a well-executed Greek bakery/café with both savory and sweet options, Pi Bakerie FiDi is a very solid choice. The ambiance is comfortable, the variety is strong, and the location is convenient. That said—if you’re after a premium boutique pastry experience (very high-end croissants or ultra artisanal desserts) or the absolute best value in town, you might find a slightly more specialised bakery elsewhere. Verdict: Recommended — especially for lunch, coffee + pastry breaks, or a casual sit‐down stop in FiDi.